Does the new iteration of the 5d stomp out its older brother? We put to the cameras to a test in a head to head at NAB2012 in a real world duke-it-out test. No charts, no controls and slightly hung-over… which camera will come up on top?
by John P. Hess
NAB has become the world’s largest convention of media geeks and nerds around. Mid-April thousands make the pilgrimage to the land of Lost Wages to get a chance to look at new equipment and ask simple questions that could have been answered by a quick Google search.
Cynicism aside, the sheer size of the convention does generate a certain electricity in the air and there’s nothing quite as exciting as seeing that new production camera on an ultra shiny monitor (especially when the monitor costs more than the camera). Plus where else can you see a free magic show that incorporates the benefits of using EMC Isilon storage solutions?
Oh yeah… and lots of Greenscreen studio setups.
There are plenty of sites that are offering complete in-depth coverage of the NAB exhibits and in the weeks and months to follow we’ll be taking a look at a lot of these new toys. In this article, we’ll just cover a few highlights – consider this a preview of things to come.
Black Magic Design Gets Into the Camera Game
Flying under the cover the big announcements from Canon and Sony regarding 4K, Black Magic Design dropped a big old, “Holy crap, that’s cool” PR bomb with their new Cinema Camera. Don’t let the simple Fisher-Price casing or lack of an alphanumeric callsign fool you, this camera is capable of some serious imaging.
Shooting on a roughly a 4/3″ chip, the Black Magic is capable of recording uncompressed 2.5K photo stream onto commonly available SSD drives. This feature is very similar to the “Digital Bolex“. But unlike the Digital Bolex, this camera can also record to a ProRes Compressed HD or DPX sequence in case you don’t want to burn hard drive space at 5 megs a frame. And doesn’t come with the retro hipster vibe.
But the best part… its selling for under $3,000.
That is the one thing I really like about Black Magic even though I don’t own anything they make. I was at another booth (who’s products I actually own) and they said a 4 way camera preview splitter was really affordable at $1,000. If Black Magic made it, it would be about $300. They really make affordable gear.
Read more about the Cinema Camera here
But I just upgraded… Adobe CS6 may be too tempting to resist
Adobe was out touting CS6… or was it. It’s sometimes hard to understand corporate double speak. Officially, CS6 is not out… so there’s no word quite yet on pricing… but all the computers a demoing CS6. So all they really can say is they’re working on it… and here it is… but it doesn’t exist yet…
The new improvements are too numerous to list here. But they are pretty substantial. Click here to see the new improvements.
The most important update is the Adobe Mercury Transmit which makes allows 3rd party hardware to access the powerful Adobe Mercury Playback engine. Previous versions had to wait for 3rd party suppliers to update their software to be compatible… hopefully this will be a thing of the past.
Autodesk’s new Smoke
I don’t know a thing about Autodesk’s Smoke. But there’s a new version and people are excited about it. I’ve never used it so I have no opinion one way or the other.
Canon’s Big 4K Cameras
I wrote a considerable article on the Canon’s 4K offerings yesterday. Neither of these cameras are really ready for market and when I tried to slip an SD card to get some sample footage, the Canon employee shooed me away.
My concerns about the 1D-C lacking an Electronic Peaking were verified. At this point, I feel like the 1D-C is what happens when you try to take the HDSLR concept too far to the point where it just doesn’t make sense.
I did get to play with the C300 and I snuck my Camera’s CF card in there to take some video. Unfortunately it formatted my card and I lost all the photos I had taken earlier in the day (which included some incriminating shots of Vincent Laforet at the Adobe Booth)… but at least the footage is really amazing.
This is compressed further as I don’t think I can upload the MXF… Horribly shot in very low light… and absolutely NO Frickin’ Noise. Amazing.
The Cine Prime lens on there was nice too…
Sony’s NEX-FS700 really is that Awesome
Unlike the overprotective parents at Canon, Sony was like that cool dad that gave you firecrackers and a BB gun and let you torment your little sister while he and aunt Julie had grown-up time in the cottage in the backyard. According the Sony representative, these 3 FS700s were the only one of their kind in the United States and they generously let me grab some footage.
These are Intra-AVC files straight off the camera – no post.
Here I am pushing the ISOs to try to see the noise. The highest I got here was about ISO5000 I think.
Here I’m looking at dynamic range between the lights and the darks. The FS700 handles the image beautifully.
As you can see the FS700 packs quite a punch for a sub-$10k camera. But
most talked about feature is the capability of shooting high frame rates (up to 240 fps for Full HD) for really cool slo mo.
What I forgot when testing out the slow motion was that high frame rate require considerably more light. And since the camera was set to auto exposure, the slow mo capture turned the ISO up to 10,000 (normally you’d never shoot that high). The amount of noise on the image didn’t become apparent until I viewed the footage on my laptop which goes to show you that having a really expensive preview monitor like the one Sony used to demo the camera does make your footage look better
Also there may be an extra post step that I’m missing that is exacerbating the noise issues (perhaps involving a missing gamma curve – I noticed if I pushed the dark areas down, it alleviated some of the noise).
Read more about the Sony NEX FS700 here
GoPro Goes Matrix
Not necessarily a new product but an interesting concept: Go Pro showed off its set up that can produce “bullet time” effects as seen on films like “The Matrix” using a modified gen-lock cable they use for the stereoscopic 3D.
No reason was given as to why it was mounted on a race car. GoPro users are just extreme that way. I’m surprised they haven’t picked up Mountain Dew as a sponsor.
The Most Awesome Van Ever
If I know my readers, the reason you clicked on the title was because you wanted to see some serious van action. Second to painting “Free WiFi” on the side of your van, nothing will gauruntee you more media nerd action than rolling into town with this sweet setup that Data Video had on display.
Play this as you scroll through the following pictures:
This video tutorial, by Jarle Leirpoll, teaches how to do primary, secondary and some pretty advanced color correction in Adobe Premiere Pro CS5.5. You’ll learn how to create masks for color correction inside of Premiere Pro, and to tweak parts of the image without affecting others.
Also covered is how to fix moiré, blown-out highlights, blue sky fix, sharpening, letterboxing, noise reduction, stabilizing and scaling/crop.
Click here to download the free preset collection “Jarle’s Grading Tools” so you can speed up your own color grading workflow.
by John P. Hess
On Sunday April 15th, 2012, the eve of the NAB Las Vegas Exhibition Week, Canon officially premiered their first line of 4K cameras to an invited group of filmmakers and press at the Dresden theater inside the Palms Hotel. The new 4K Canons included the EOS 1D-C, the world’s first 4K HDSLR camera, and the EOS C500, the 4K big brother of last year’s C300.
Having driven from California (with a 2 hour detour after I realized I left my camera at home) I arrived exhausted but just in time for the event. The place was packed with seating only available in the front 4 rows. Now normally I would have shyed away from sitting so close to the screen, but having recently read up on the biological limitations of the human eye I felt that sitting in the front would be the perfect place to really get the full impact of 4K projection.**
**Aside: Using a screen calculator estimating a 50 foot screen (600 inches), I would have to sit a maximum of 37 feet away (American Football fans, imagine a little more than 10 yards) from the screen to fully appreciate the pixel count of 4K (this is because the 20/20 human eyesight resolves only to 1/60th of a degree, and my eyes are far from 20/20). So if I was really going to pixel peep a 4K projection, the third row was the place to do it.
The event started with the usual corporate heraldry sounding off on the greatness of Canon’s camera offerings. It was preaching to the choir as almost every camera in the room carried the Canon logo. And we all knew the news. What we really wanted to see were the demo films and get more specs.
Instead of a blow by blow recount of the evenings show, I’m just going to boil it down to just what you need to know about these cameras. If you need more information, the web is full of tech rich discussions on these cameras to aid your purchasing/rental desires.
I’m going to start with C500 – the KING of Canon’s Video Cameras. There has been some lamenting as to why the C500, which has essentially the same imaging chip as the C300, wasn’t the first to be released. But if you know anything about showmanship, you know you want to save the best for last.
But there was a technical reason as well. To many of us, a video camera is a mystery black box: Light goes in one end and it gets stored as data on these little square pieces of plastic. What I gathered from the engineering explaination (which had words I recognized but combined in the manner of explaining the C500′s image processing managed to flow right over my head) the C500 required a greater amount of technical voodoo to hand off all those pretty pixels.
These are pictures of the slide show from Adam Wilt’s blog on the screening at ProVideoCoalition
Okay… now I get it!
A short film "Man and Beast" shot by Jeff Cronenweth showcased the Canon C500′s capability. And it is quite a remarkable capability. The film was told through narration and visual story telling. Pixel peeping from the 3rd row, the images were about as visually perfect as I could tell. There was a shot of a tiger (or lioness – I forget) that would have rivaled any National Georgaphic photo.
To be fair, my experience isn’t with cameras of this high a calibur but everything about the image from the focus to the fleshtones to the sharpness all just felt right. It was CINEMA with a capital C.
At $30,000 it should be.
But I have to remark on the length of ending credits… any short film with a list of names that long had better look damned good.
Okay, maybe the $30k C500 is too much dought to spend (or even rent). What about the 4K HDSLR?
The technicalities of the 4K are rather interesting and totally explained to the layman this way:
Well, jah….. duh…
All kidding aside, it basically means the video image sensor crop varies depending on the type of video you are shooting. So if you shoot 4K you’ll get a slightly smaller center cropped field of view than shooting HD (which can be switched between full frame and Super 35).
But does it shoot good?
"The Ticket" was the demo film presented by Shane Hurlbut from the 5D MkII Act of Valor fame (click here to see the film). Shot on the streets of Santa Monica at night mostly handheld, "The Ticket" used mostly natural light with a just a little help ("4 amps only" as described by Hurlbut on one dark shot on a ferris wheel).
The Ticket told a story of a young couple having a long overdue date at the pier… oh who am I kidding.
No one watches these kinds of films for plots… certainly not from the third row.
So how did it look?
Good… with a very big "BUT"
When the 1D-C was fed a ton of light the 4K really popped. No Moire artifacts (why should there be? the camera doesn’t down sample) and no noticeable rolling shutter at least in what they were showing us. The video noise, what little there was to be seen, had a the much talked about "organic look" that didn’t scream, "I’m video noise! Look at me!"
The low light shots out on the streets, while still an amazing accomplishment in terms of low light aquisition, was were the camera starts to show some signs of "breaking down". And by "breaking down" I use that in the lightest and most delicate sense as it still blows almost everything else out of the water. There were couple shots in a running sequence where the resolution inexplicably drops down perhaps due to some post-stabalizing work done. And in the very final shot which was a wide of the Santa Monica Pier lit up at night, the highlights coming off the ocean had a distinctively harsh "video" look to them.
No, you can’t tell from this screengrab…
These issues could be explained by any number of the things. It could be a matter of my tastes generally lean toward more enhanced looks over flat natural lighting which is why I wasn’t sold totally on the low light shots… Let’s just say, it was EXCELLENT, but no C500
But… and here’s the real kicker.
There were quite a few shots that were slightly out of focus. And this is not reflecting poorly on Mr. Hurlbut or his crew… it’s the limitation of the camera.
Here’s a few samples I pulled from a screen Vimeo stream on Shane Hurlbut’s site. Now… this is a 720p stream with NO SCALING… so the difference is kind of ridculously small to the point where you should be yelling at the screen, "C’mon!" And you’d be right… but here we are talking about 4K when the primary mode of delivery is internet at 720p.
But I think you can still see them… and if you can barely pick them out at 720p, they’re noticeable at 4K. You’ll need to expand these images and really lean in to see any differences between these images:
Look closely at the moustache… the shot on the left is a smidge softer than the razor sharp moustache on the right. And that’s one of those things about 4K… when it’s sharp in 4K, its POPS – so you can tell when it’s not (especially from the 3rd row sitting in front of a 50 foot screen).
Here’s another example… this is a push in and rotate – hard to pull focus anyway… so its bound to float in and out of focus. But when shooting 4K – this incredible small flaws get blown up big time.
Two more examples… and we’ve all done this when shooting HDSLR.
Here’s the problem… The Canon 1D-C DOES NOT OUTPUT a 4K signal. It does output a 1080p signal but that’s almost like trying to focus an HD image using a SD signal.
Now if Canon would have included "Peaking" in this release, this might be resolve the issue. But there is no peaking. So there is absolutely no visual confirmation you are getting the exact critical focus. You are flying based solely on those numbers on the side of the lens – and you can’t be off by even a hair…
And this is moment where I think everyone out there getting ready to ditch their HDSLRs and jump onboard the 4K bandwagon needs to stop and think.
Imagine the same issues pulling focus you have with shooting HDSLR with the micro focusing errors being squared.
Now… let me make this point really clear: The level of pixel peeping here is reaching the "asshole-troll" level. And you probably won’t catch this sitting further back in a theater (to which I ask, at what point does the line between 2K and 4K blur?)
But this focusing blind is one major issue I see with a camera of this capability, especially if I’m going to shell out $15K (or a little less) for the body alone. The C500 demo film did not have these issues (that camera has electronic peaking and they also shot mostly locked down or on dolly with a crew reaching up to 100 whereas The Ticket was shot mostly handheld an small crew).
I have been a more than a little skeptical of 4K in the past. I’m not necessarily reversing my opinions on 4K but I can really appreciate the beauty of it when blown up on a large screen.
But speaking as a low budget filmmaker I’m really concerned that 4K will make things worse rather than better. When you have sharp focused images popping out, it just highlights the other shots that aren’t quite in focus. And that’s not to mention the post pipeline needed to handle it.
Ultimately it comes down to creating that connection between the audience and the story playing on the screen. I think HD and 2K is enough to provide that immersive environment. 4K is gorgeous, but unless you can pull it off perfectly (which means you have all the gear and a fully professional crew who can really nail it), I worry that those minor errors will end up taking people out of the story rather than keeping them in.
Color Reel, is an animation that quizzes your knowledge of colors in film.
Mr Foley is an award winning short film directed by Dublin directing duo Mike Ahern & Enda Loughman aka D.A.D.D.Y. It’s a darkly funny but nightmarish scenario, a man wakes up in hospital with a group of sound artists soundtracking his life.
John Hess talks about the buzz around the new 4k cameras and refines his stance on where you can implement 4k.
Listen Audio Only:
7 6 Articles of the Week:
Because we all know what was missing from Titanic was Storm Troopers…. and Billy Zane shot first.
The Trailer for Evil Dead 2 rotoscoped by “Pretend For Real.” Rotoscoping is an animation technique in which animators trace over live-action film movement, frame by frame, for use in animated films. It’s an extremely tedious process that took these creators 3 years to complete.
The names may not be recognizable, but their voices are household staples. Even in an era where Animation studios are trying to insure their films with A-List celebrities as voice actors, there’s something unique and wonderful about those behind-the-scene actors who really elevated voice acting to another level. “I Know That Voice” explores their work including appearances by Billy West, John Di Maggio, Tara Strong, and June Foray.
Aspiring filmmakers often let the contract and business details of film production be an afterthought, thinking “that’s not fun. Or creative. And I don’t have the budget for that un-fun, un-creative stuff. I’m working with my friends… it’ll all be fine.”
But they’re unlikely to do so again after the many problems arise (which they always do) and perhaps render their hard work practically and commercially unusable. Neglecting contracts and business formalities may prevent getting investors for your film, or may cause a host of other problems that mean a film cannot get interest or distribution.
What follows is a brief list of a few critical “what and why” business details that filmmakers must do, from the outset, to minimize obstacles to a film or project’s success.
This is a shootout of the new Nikon D800 and Canon 5D mkIII DSLRs, with a focus on the video quality in particular.
The cool camera stuff happens in Vegas